The Chief Information Commissioner of Tripura, Binoy Shankar Mishra, in his latest order on an appeal filed by Jagdish Rawat, Office Secretary of the Chakma Development Foundation of India (CDFI), issued show-cause notices to S. Prabhu, Additional Secretary, Tribal Welfare Department, asking him to explain why a fine of Rs 25,000 should not be imposed and disciplinary action initiated for denying information on the Chakma Customary Law Act.
On 28 August 2023, Jagdish Rawat filed an RTI application with the Tribal Welfare Department of Tripura, seeking copies of communications regarding the Chakma Customary Laws Act of 2022, copies of submissions made by Chakma organisations, opinions of the Tribal Welfare Department regarding the Act, and certified copies of the Act. The then Additional Secretary, S. Prabhu, acting as the Public Information Officer (PIO) and subsequently as the First Appellate Authority, denied the information on the false ground that the matter was pending before the State Legislature. He also forwarded the RTI application to a private NGO, Chakma Miley Jodha (Chakma Women's Association) to furnish information.
Jagdish Rawat filed an appeal before the Tripura Information Commission, stating that the entire decision of Mr S Prabhu was legally invalid and that the claim that the matter was pending before the State Legislature was absolutely false, fictitious and a lie, as the State Legislature had no role in the matter.
The Chief Information Commissioner, in an order made available on Thursday, stated that there was a total failure to establish legislative privilege and that the denial of information was legally unsustainable. The Commission held that transferring the RTI application to Chakma Miley Jodha (Chakma Women's Association) "was legally unsustainable and amounted to a failure to apply the statutory scheme governing access to information".
Mr. Prabhu acted as the PIO and the First Appellate Authority and reviewed his own decisions, in violation of the Delhi High Court judgment in Suhas Chakma v. Union of India & Others dated 18 November 2011 which had held that the Central Information Commission (CIC) does not have the power to review its own orders. The Commission concluded that the explanation furnished by Mr. Prabhu failed to establish that he had acted reasonably, satisfactorily and diligently, or that he had provided any valid statutory basis for denying the information.
The Chief Information Commissioner further stated that there was a delay of 1,131 days between 2 September 2023 and 6 October 2026. Although the fine for not providing the information at the rate of Rs 250 per day would amount to Rs 2,82,750, Section 20(1) of the RTI Act expressly limits the total monetary penalty to Rs 25,000. The Commission therefore imposed a fine of Rs 25,000, the maximum penalty permitted under the RTI Act.
The Commission was satisfied that Mr. Prabhu had knowingly provided incorrect, incomplete and misleading information to the applicant, Jagdish Rawat. The Commission further issued show-cause notices to S. Prabhu, the then Additional Secretary, under Section 20(1) of the Act, read with the applicable service rules, asking him to explain why disciplinary proceedings should not be initiated under Section 20(2) of the RTI Act for failure to ensure the furnishing of information within the statutory period; denial of information on the basis of an unsupported invocation of Section 8(1)(c); furnishing of incorrect or misleading statutory grounds for denial; continued non-correction of the statutory default; and persistent failure to discharge the statutory obligations incumbent upon him as the deemed State Public Information Officer (SPIO).
The Chakma Customary Law Act violates the basic principles of the Constitution of India and the laws of the land, has been opposed by the CDFI, Chakma Miley Jodha and others was rejected by the Tripura Law Department.